By John R. Rapasky
Beginning January 1, 2010, a new 3-page Good Faith Estimate (“GFE”) will go into effect. For the first time, the GFE will be a uniform document, to be used by all mortgage brokers and bankers. The purpose of this new form is to make it easier for you to shop for a loan. However, a closer examination of this form is necessary to safeguard against misleading information.
A GFE must be issued within 3 business days of the application. In order to issue a GFE, it is presumed the loan originator has the following 6 pieces of information: borrower’s name, loan amount, estimate of the value of the property, property address, borrower’s monthly income, and borrower’s social security number in order to obtain a credit report. After obtaining and reviewing this information, the loan originator can issue a GFE.
The first page contains new information that was not on the previous GFE. The first page provides time lines for how long the quoted interest rate is available, the time period the estimated settlement charges are available, the time period the interest rate is locked, and the amount of time to lock the rate before settlement. The settlement charges quoted are good for 10 business days. The borrower has 10 business days from the date of the GFE to give intent to go forward with the loan. If no intent is given by the borrower, then the GFE is no longer valid.
The first page also summarizes the loan product being offered. It quotes the loan amount, loan term, and interest rate, and provides specific information regarding the loan product. It provides information such as: whether the interest rate can rise, can the loan balance increase even if you make your payments on time, can the monthly mortgage payment increase even if you make your payments on time, whether the loan has a pre-payment penalty, and whether there is a balloon payment. In the event of any of these circumstances, the form provides for additional information such as the maximum amount the interest rate can rise, the maximum amount the loan balance can rise, the amount the monthly payment can increase, the maximum amount the monthly payment can increase, the amount of the pre-payment penalty, and the amount of the balloon payment. In addition, towards the bottom of the first page, it provides whether an escrow account for paying homeowners insurance and taxes is required.
At the bottom of the first page is the summary of the settlement charges, which are itemized on page 2.
Page 2 has two parts. The top portion, summarized in Line A, is the origination charges, and the bottom part, summarized in Line B, contains the settlement charges. The top portion, the origination charges, contains two blocks. Block 1 includes the origination charge which includes items such as underwriting fees, processing fees, origination fees, and the yield spread premium that is paid to the mortgage broker. Block 2 contains 3 boxes. Box 1, used mainly by banks, notes any charges or credits for the interest rate quoted. Box 2 gives a credit for the interest rate chosen, typically the yield spread premium paid to the mortgage broker. Box 3 provides for any origination fees for the loan. What has changed from the current GFE is there is no longer an itemization of loan origination charges. Also, the banks do not need to disclose their commission on this form, only the mortgage brokers. The origination charges are summarized in Line A, the adjusted origination charges. These charges cannot increase at settlement.
The second part contains the charges for all other settlement services. Block 3 itemizes services required to be completed for settlement that are selected by the lender, e.g. appraisal, credit report, tax service, flood certification, up front mortgage insurance premium, VA funding fee, and subordination agreement fee. Block 4 includes the lender’s title services and escrow fees, e.g. escrow fee, title insurance, and title endorsements. Block 5 is for the owner’s title policy, which the seller typically purchases in a purchase transaction (owner’s title will probably not be provided in a refinance transaction). Block 6 is required services you can shop for, such as survey and termite inspection fees. Block 7 is the government recording charge. If the borrower uses the lender’s selections of providers from Blocks 3-7, then these charges cannot increase by more than 10% at settlement. If the charges are in excess of 10%, then there is a “tolerance violation,” and the lender is required to pay for the difference.
Block 8 is for transfer taxes. This charge cannot increase at settlement.
The charges in the remaining Blocks on page 2 can change at settlement. Block 9 is the initial deposit into the escrow account to pay future homeowners insurance and property tax charges. Block 10 is the prepaid interest charge. Block 11 is the homeowner’s insurance premium required to be paid at closing. The total for all of the other settlement services are summarized on Line B.
The bottom of the form totals the estimated settlement charges from Lines A and B. These totals also appear on the first page of the form.
The third page of the GFE provides comparison tables for different scenarios. The tradeoff table allows the customer to review different scenarios with different rates and closing costs. The shopping chart at the bottom allows the customer to shop different GFEs from different lenders.
In general, once the GFE is issued, it cannot be changed. However, there are certain circumstances, called “changed circumstances”, where the GFE can change after it is issued. Changed circumstances are defined as: (1) Acts of God, war, disaster, or other emergency; (2) Information particular to the borrower or transaction that was relied on in providing the GFE and that changes or is found to be inaccurate after the GFE has been provided, which information may include information about the credit quality of the borrower, the amount of the loan, the estimated value of the property, or any other information that was used in providing the GFE; (3) New information particular to the borrower or transaction that was not relied on in providing the GFE; or (4) Other circumstances that are particular to the borrower or transaction, including boundary disputes, the need for flood insurance, or environmental problems. Once a changed circumstance is known, a new GFE must be issued within 3 business days.
Notwithstanding the changes to the GFE, the form omits information that would be important in shopping for a loan. The following are 10 items that would be important in shopping for a loan that are not on the new GFE: (1) whether the loan is for a primary residence, second/vacation home, or investment property; (2) the purchase price or estimated value of the property; (3) the loan-to-value ratio, or down payment; (4) the type of loan program, i.e. conventional, VA, FHA, USDA, etc.; (5) the amount of cash needed to close; (6) an indication of what are the APR impacting fees; (7) itemization of the lender’s charges; (8) a provision for the seller’s contribution towards closing costs; (9) the amount of HOA fees; (10) and the total payment including taxes and insurance. Each of these items is important and could affect the terms quoted in the GFE. Because these items are not in the new GFE, you can be misled. Thus, you should not rely solely on the GFE and you should ask questions.
In sum, the new GFE is an improvement from what previously existed. It does provide information to the borrower to shop for a loan. But, as existed with the previous GFE, the customer should work with someone they trust and ask questions to make sure they are obtaining the loan that is right for them. We, at Counsel Mortgage Group, LLC, specialize in helping you find the right loan. Contact us and we can help you with the new GFE, and in finding a loan.
John Rapasky is the President of the Counsel Mortgage Group, LLC. You can learn about them at www.counselmortgage.com. Copyright © 2009 Counsel Mortgage Group®, LLC